Emotion Vs . Reason - the Fight for Survival Dissertation

Feelings Versus Purpose - the Fight for Your survival

The antagonistic romance between rational reason and emotional desire has been worrying philosophers and psychologists likewise for many years. Whilst these two makes must co-exist for the human soul to outlive, it is up the soul to look for balance between your two. The narratives present in Primo Levi's book, The Periodic Stand, provide primary examples of the fight among emotion and reason. The chapters ‘Mercury', ‘Sulfur' and ‘Titanium' will be narratives, and each chapter illustrates one prime emotion; jealousy, anger and fear respectively. It is to the protagonist in each part to conquer their feeling in order to listen to reason. Through his narratives, Levi's personas prove that feelings limit logical judgment, where success in survival is usually stemmed from the cabability to ignore emotions and listen to reason. Authorities in the field of emotion, logic and cognitive values have discussed the topic of emotion versus reasoning for a very long time. While some find their contradictory relationship arguable, many even now believe that they may be opposing causes, destined to remain irreconcilable. Dating all the way to classic Greece, Plato recommended the chariot allegory when the human soul is ruled by two opposing race horses; one representing spiritual boldness, the various other representing animalian desire. The fight among logic and emotion is very similar to the type in the sense that these two opposition forces govern moral common sense. Even today, this kind of relationship is being discussed. In respect to thinker Patricia Greenspan, emotional claims such as anger, fear, envy, contempt, misery, disgust, delight, pride and shame " are commonly thought of as antithetical to reason, disorienting and damaging practical thought” (Kirman, 2). Peter Goldie of the College or university of Gatwick also confirms that " we are willing to say which our emotions may and do greatly distort the view of things” (Goldie, 1), fighting that " our thoughts can deceived us profoundly” (2). As...

References: Dorian, Pam. " Charioteer Type. " The Digital Dialogue. N. g., n. m. Web. 9

Apr. 2013..

Goldie, Philip. " Feelings, Reason and Virtue. " Emotion, Development and

Rationality 1 (2004): 249-267. Print.

Kirman, Alan, Pierre Livet, and Miriam Teschl. " Rationality and Emotions. "

Philosophical Ventures of the Hoheitsvoll Philosophy 365. 1538 (2009): 215-219. Net. 8 April. 2013.

Levi, Primo. The Routine Table. Nyc: Schocken Books, 1984. Print out.